
Holiday Financial Stress: How to Budget for the Holidays Without the Guilt
“I know we can’t afford it. I’m buying it anyway.” “I don’t want the kids to feel like they got less than their cousins.” “I’ll figure out the credit card in January.” Maybe you are the one who keeps the list. You track who gets what, which teacher still needs a gift card, and how much is left in the account after the mortgage. And somewhere under the wrapping paper, there is a quiet knot that tightens every time you tap your card. Holiday financial stress is the anxiety, guilt and dread that build when holiday spending pulls against what a household can afford. It is rarely only about money. For many women, it is tied to beliefs about being a good mother, daughter or host. A values-based budget lowers holiday financial stress by deciding in advance what the spending is for.How common is holiday financial stress?
Very. In the American Psychiatric Association’s November 2025 Healthy Minds Poll, 46% of adults said they were worried about affording or finding holiday gifts. That made it the second most common holiday worry, just behind grief. The bills tell the same story. LendingTree’s survey of 2,032 consumers, fielded December 10–15, 2025, found that 37% took on holiday debt, averaging $1,223. Forty-one percent of those borrowers were still paying off the previous year’s holidays. Parents had it hardest: 48% of parents with children under 18 borrowed to cover the season. If you have been quietly carrying this, you are in a very large and very silent group.
It is not really about the gifts: Holiday Financial Stress
Here is what most budgeting advice misses: women rarely overspend at the holidays because they cannot do math. They overspend because they love people, and somewhere along the way, love got tied to a price tag. Underneath the extra stocking stuffers, there is usually a sentence. A good mom makes Christmas magical. If I host, it has to be perfect. My family will think less of me if I show up with less. Psychologists Paul Hewitt and Gordon Flett, in their 1991 work published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, called one version of this socially-prescribed perfectionism: the belief that other people hold standards you must meet to be acceptable. December puts those imagined standards everywhere, from the neighbor’s lights to the cousin’s gift haul. So the overspending is not a character flaw. It is the cost of a virtue. Generosity and devotion are real strengths. The trouble starts when they are driven by fear of not being enough, instead of by what you actually want to give.The overspending is rarely about the gifts. It is about the fear that your love will not be enough without them.For women who are their household’s primary earner, the weight doubles. You may be carrying the financial load and the invisible holiday work at the same time: the planning, the shopping and the remembering. That is a lot to hold, and it is worth saying out loud.
How to budget for the holidays around your values: Holiday Financial Stress
This is not a spreadsheet lesson. It is a way to make spending decisions from what matters to you instead of from guilt. It comes from Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), the evidence-based approach at the core of Empower’s work.- Start with the memory, not the money. Ask yourself: Ten years from now, what do I want my people to remember about this season? Maya Angelou put it well: “People will never forget how you made them feel.” Most women answer with something like time together, a tradition, or feeling at ease. Very few say “the number of boxes.”
- Name your number before the store does. Choose a total you can pay off when the January statement arrives. Write it down. A number you chose on a calm Tuesday holds up better than one you negotiate with yourself in the checkout line.
- Sort your list into two columns. One column is where it matters to me. The other is where it can be simple. Spend generously in the first column. Let the second be easy and inexpensive, or let it go entirely.
- Say the change out loud, early. Families usually adjust when they hear it before the shopping starts. A few scripts:
- “We’re doing a $25 gift swap with the cousins this year instead of buying for everyone.”
- “We’re giving experiences this year. We’d love to take you to lunch in January.”
- “I’m not hosting the big dinner this year, but I’d love to bring a side dish.”
- Notice the urge, then choose. When you feel the pull to add one more thing, pause and name the thought: I’m having the thought that the kids will be disappointed. Naming it creates a little distance. From there, you can check it against your list instead of obeying it automatically.
When the guilt shows up anyway: Holiday Financial Stress
It probably will. Cutting back can feel like failing, especially if your own childhood holidays were tight and you promised yourself your kids would never feel that. The guilt is not proof you are doing it wrong. It is the old rule talking: love equals more. ACT does not ask you to make the guilt disappear before you act. It asks you to let it come along while you do what fits your values. You can feel a pang at the toy aisle and still walk past it. Children are also more resilient than the ads suggest. What tends to stay with them is the mood of the house: whether the adults seemed calm, present and glad to be there. If holiday debt is already heavy, a nonprofit credit counselor can help you plan the numbers. Empower’s therapists are not financial advisors. Our part is the anxiety, shame and perfectionism that make money so hard to talk about.Quick answers
Is it normal to feel anxious about money during the holidays? Yes. Gift costs were the second most common holiday worry in the APA’s 2025 poll, named by 46% of adults. You are not bad with money for feeling it. How do I tell my family I’m spending less on gifts this year? Tell them early and keep it simple. Offer what you will do instead, like a gift swap, a shared outing or a homemade tradition. You do not owe a long explanation. How do I stop feeling guilty about not buying my kids more? Remember what you are actually trying to give them. Write down what you want them to remember, and let that guide the season. Guilt is a feeling to make room for, not an order to follow.What becomes possible
Picture a January without the knot in your stomach when the statement comes. Picture a December where you are actually at the table, instead of running the numbers in your head while everyone opens presents. That is not a smaller holiday. It is a holiday that fits your life and your values. When money anxiety is part of a bigger pattern, like chronic worry, perfectionism or the weight of being the one who holds everything together, that is the work Empower’s therapists do every day in our anxiety therapy and therapy for professionals. Empower’s founder, Kathryn Ely, JD, LPC, works with women who are their family’s primary breadwinners and are tired of feeling like they are never doing enough. Ready to stop carrying it alone? Schedule a free 15-minute consultation. In person in Birmingham · Online throughout Alabama.More from Empower
Since this post argues that holiday overspending is rarely about money and usually about the fear of not being enough, here is where to take that fear instead of to the checkout line, so you can find your therapist in Birmingham. If the worry is constant, start with anxiety counseling in Birmingham, help for panic attacks, or perfectionism counseling with founder Kathryn Ely, who works with primary-breadwinner mothers and women in counseling for professionals and counseling for lawyers/attorneys. If the season has left you flat rather than wired, depression therapy in Birmingham can help. If money is tangled up with a divorce, a move or a career change, Marti Burton specializes in therapy for life transitions, along with trauma and PTSD treatment, EMDR therapy and OCD therapy. The rest of the team brings its own specialties. Payton Wortman treats eating disorders and body image and social anxiety using IFS. Hannah Hattaway treats eating disorders and OCD and offers premarital counseling, where couples can talk about money before it becomes a fight. Anna Mills Fleenor provides PMAD therapy, and Brook Sullivan helps women who have come to believe their body is broken and it is all their fault. Savannah Thrower offers ADHD therapy, neurodivergent-informed therapy and counseling for parents of neurodivergent children. Dymond Callen, DMSc, PA-C, offers medication management in Birmingham. All of our therapy is grounded in ACT in Birmingham, for teens, college students, young adults and beyond. If money was ever used to control you, Cathrine Barnett, M.Ed., ALC, offers emotional abuse and relational trauma therapy, along with couples counseling for partners who keep fighting about it. We see clients at our Mountain Brook office, a short drive from Vestavia Hills, Trussville, Homewood and Forest Park. Online counseling reaches the rest of Alabama, including Auburn and Tuscaloosa, and online counseling in Tennessee is available with select clinicians. Students at Auburn University, Vanderbilt, the University of Alabama and Samford can meet with us online. Because this post is about money: our rates and payment page explains costs up front. You can also read the FAQ, take the quiz, learn about Empower, or visit the homepage. More Blog Posts for You:How to Set Boundaries With Family During the Holidays (Without Feeling Like the Bad Guy)
Manage Perfectionism and Anxiety in Neurodivergent Teens
Sources
- American Psychiatric Association, Americans More Anxious About the Holidays, Healthy Minds Poll, November 4–5, 2025, 2,203 U.S. adults.
- LendingTree holiday debt survey, December 10–15, 2025, 2,032 U.S. consumers, as reported by Chain Store Age and Wharton Baker Retailing Center. Link LendingTree’s own study page when publishing.
- Hewitt, P. L., & Flett, G. L. (1991). Perfectionism in the self and social contexts. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 60(3), 456–470.




